Dr. Elsey’s Ultra is a clay litter, and Noisy Lion is a tofu litter made from pea fibre and plant starches, with bentonite added. In the 1–3 star reviews of Dr. Elsey’s Ultra on Amazon.ca, the most common complaint we found is dust (14 of 45 we read). Our tofu line has an independent lab report from CTI showing 99.9% dust-free and 99.1% odour removal. Buyers also tell us it clumps firmly and scoops in one piece.
tofu litter
Ultra, unscented
Dr. Elsey’s details from drelseys.com (Ultra) and petsmart.ca (Precious Cat Ultra Clumping Multi-Cat Clay Cat Litter, Unscented, 40 lb), checked November 5, 2026. Noisy Lion figures from our product pages and CTI report A2260218535101001E (tofu line).
Complaint counts: we read 45 of the most helpful and most recent 1–3 star reviews of Dr. Elsey’s Ultra on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. They are a share of those critical reviews, not of all buyers.
Why people choose Noisy Lion
Dust you can check
CTI, an independent lab, tested our tofu line. It measured 0.1% powder content, which is 99.9% dust-free. You can read the full report on our site. Dr. Elsey’s lists Ultra as 99% dust-free on its own site. The PetSmart listing says 99.9%. We didn’t find a lab report for either of its numbers.
“…Pouring this litter releases dust clouds, like a miniature sandstorm in your living room.”1-star review on Amazon.ca, April 2025
“…no dust and the lovely smell!”Verified buyer, noisylion.ca, July 2026
Clumps that don’t stick
Our tofu litter clumps faster and harder than clay. The bentonite helps each clump hold together, so it lifts out whole. Our Natural Cassava line doesn’t stick to the bottom of the box when you fill it about 7 cm deep.
“It clumps really well and doesn't stick to the litter box, making cleanup super easy.”Verified purchase, Walmart.ca, February 2026
Less litter on the floor
Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. Ours are about 1.5 mm.
“I have 3 cats and they like it too. Very little tracking.”Verified buyer, noisylion.ca, August 2026
Odour control with a lab number
CTI also tested odour in our tofu line. It removed 99.1% of odour in their test. You can choose a light tea scent or our unscented Natural Cassava line. We didn’t find an odour figure on the Dr. Elsey’s product page.
“It clumps amazing and keeps the smell to a minimum.”Verified buyer, noisylion.ca, November 2025
When Dr. Elsey’s is the better fit
Choose Dr. Elsey’s if price per kilo matters most. At PetSmart the Ultra 40 lb (18.14 kg) bag was $31.99 on November 5, 2026. That is about $1.76 a kilo, against $4.92 for our 12 kg bag. Ultra is unscented, with no perfumes or deodorants. Dr. Elsey’s also makes Cat Attract, a litter blended with a natural herb attractant for cats that have house-soiling problems.
Which of our three litters is right for you?
Three formulas, one lab standard. Subscription price shown first (10% off every delivery; change or cancel anytime).



Questions people ask
What do Dr. Elsey’s buyers complain about?
We read 45 critical (1–3 star) reviews of Dr. Elsey’s Ultra on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. Of those, 14 mentioned dust, 12 said it costs too much or runs out fast, and 11 said it sticks to the box. Our tofu line tested 99.9% dust-free with CTI, an independent lab. Our Natural Cassava line doesn’t stick to the bottom of the box when you fill it about 7 cm deep.
What is Dr. Elsey’s Ultra made of?
Dr. Elsey’s lists one ingredient for Ultra, natural clay. Our tofu litter is pea fibre and plant starches, with bentonite added. Our Natural Cassava line has no bentonite.
Which controls odour better?
Both brands say they control odour. Ours was tested by CTI, an independent lab. It removed 99.1% of odour in the test of our tofu line. Dr. Elsey’s doesn’t publish an odour figure for Ultra that we could find.
Is Dr. Elsey’s cheaper than Noisy Lion?
Per kilo, yes. At PetSmart the 40 lb Ultra bag was $31.99 (about $1.76 a kilo) on November 5, 2026. Our 12 kg bag is $4.92 a kilo, or $4.42 on subscription.
Can I flush Dr. Elsey’s or Noisy Lion?
Dr. Elsey’s says not to flush Ultra. You can flush a few clumps of our tofu litter at a time if your municipality allows it, but never on a septic system. Never flush our cassava line. See our disposal guide.
Dr. Elsey’s information comes from drelseys.com and petsmart.ca (Precious Cat Ultra, 40 lb), checked November 5, 2026. Complaint counts come from 1–3 star reviews on Amazon.ca, read November 8, 2026. Dr. Elsey’s current prices and terms take precedence. Customer quotes are individual experiences. Noisy Lion lab figures are for our tofu line (CTI report A2260218535101001E). Dr. Elsey’s and Precious Cat are trademarks of their owner; this article is not affiliated with or endorsed by Dr. Elsey’s.